Showing posts with label Immigration. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Immigration. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 11, 2008

DHS 1, Families 0

The March 3 New Yorker has a heartbreaking, horrifying story about the detention of immigrant families (unfortunately, not online). The story focuses on one of two such facilities, in Middleofnowhere, Texas; run by a private contractor with a spotty record, it's a bleak cheerless prison with no concession to the needs of the families incarcerated there--many of whom are asylum-seekers who have already established a 'well-founded fear of persecution' in their home countries. The situation is a multi-car pile-up of nativism, paranoia, bureaucratic ineptitude, obsessive secrecy, privatization gone wild, and a deep-seated contempt for civil liberties--in other words, the fundamentals of Republican ideology. One sentence kind of sums up how we got here:

The detention of immigrants is the fastest-growing form of incarceration in the country, and, with the support of the Bush Administration, it is becoming a lucrative business.
A lucrative business, it should be noted, for correctional corporations whose contracts were drying up because they did such a lousy job with our home-grown inmates.

It should also be noted that there is an alternative (other than 'catch-and-release') to keeping these folks in prison:
The report recommended a new alternative to detention known as the Intensive Supervision Appearance Program--which allows people awaiting disposition of their immigration cases to be released into the community, provided that they are closely tracked by means such as electronic monitoring bracelets, curfews, and regular contact with a caseworker. The government has since established pilot programs in twelve cities, and reports that more than ninety percent of the people enrolled in them showed up for their court dates.
But of course the DHS went for prison instead. Because nothing less would satisfy the Michelle Malkins of America.

Thursday, December 20, 2007

Tancredomentum!

Tom Tancredo is out of the race. Too bad; I was rooting for him to get the nomination, as the best chance for a 50-state Democratic win.

Let's not be too sad for the crazy nativist scumbags, though; they still have plenty of candidates to choose from.

Update: And if you're wondering what went wrong for Tancredo, it's obviously his name. The people who make up his natural constituency all thought he was a Mexican.

Tuesday, December 18, 2007

Return of 'Maverick' McCain

I was reading Ryan Lizza's New Yorker piece on the Tancredoist transformation of the Republican party (great title: "Return of the Nativist"), and it made me nostalgic for the McCain of yore--the 'principled' 'maverick' we used to hear so much about. Lizza focuses on McCain as the sole Republican holdout, the one candidate who isn't pandering shamelessly to the nativist lunatic fringe.

And we who know better could be forgiven for rolling our eyes at yet another paean to McCain's 'integrity'. We've heard it all before; we know it's a sham, a pose to ingratiate himself with the Washington press corps. When someone uses 'McCain' and 'principles' in the same sentence, the first image I see is him hugging George Bush.

At the same time, McCain is genuinely less awful than the rest. Romney and Giuliani are the worst, having renounced relatively decent immigration policies in favor of the scapegoating demagoguery they hope will make the base happy, but the others aren't far behind. In this field, on this issue, McCain really is showing something that approaches what you could call integrity, if you squint hard.

Which, I realized, is the key to the whole McCain thing. Read between the lines, go beyond the intent of the authors. All of the gushing press, all of those pieces about Saint John McCain--they were never really about McCain. They were about the Republican Party. When someone calls McCain 'independent', they're really saying the GOP is the Borg. When they say he's a 'straight shooter', it's a comment on the craven mendacity of his opponents. When they talk about his 'integrity', it's really a comment on the stinking cesspool the party has become.

And yeah, McCain bows down to the Party when it really matters; his positions are hostage to political expediency; and he's dirty just like the rest. McCain is really, really bad.

It's just that the Republican party as a whole is even worse.

Monday, October 29, 2007

One Klan Group to Protest Another in Cullman AL

Um, what? Geez, just how many Klan members are there in Cullman?

Members of one Ku Klux Klan organization say they will assemble at the courthouse Nov. 10 to show their opposition to another Klan group that plans an anti-immigration rally there that day.

Ken Mier, who described himself as an investigator for the Alabama Ku Klux Klan and the national office of the Ku Klux Klan LLC, said in an e-mail to The Cullman Times that his group is against the tactics of the National Knights of the Ku Klux Klan, which held an anti-immigration protest last month in Athens.

"We are opposed to the ignorance and stupidity as displayed by the individuals that thumbed their nose at the area churches by continuing to use racial slurs, threats and avoided Christian deportment," he said.

Okay, I'm speculating here -- there's not much information in the linked news flash -- but somehow I doubt the Alabama Klan loves them some immigrants. Sounds like the local folks are just a mite pissed that the damnyankees came down here and stole their thunder.

Monday, July 09, 2007

Nativism vs. National Security

Last Friday, I wrote about why 'closing the border' is exactly the wrong thing to do in the interests of national security. Today, Kevin Drum links to an article suggesting yet another reason why this is true. The article deals with the question of why Europe has had more Islamist terrorist attacks than the US:

Karl-Heinz Kamp, the security policy coordinator at Germany's prestigious Konrad Adenauer research center, said..."The U.S. has a historical advantage; America is still the land of opportunity to the whole world. The people moving there believe the American dream of social mobility," he said. "In Europe, we've historically treated our immigrants as hired help, and waited for them to finish the work they arrived for and go home."

Bob Ayers, a security and terrorism expert with London's Chatham House, a foreign-policy research center, thinks that immigrants to the U.S. actually become Americans, giving the United States a huge advantage in avoiding homegrown al Qaida terrorists.
Which is exactly the advantage the Know-Nothings would throw away.

Kevin adds:
I wish this could be stapled on the foreheads of Tom Tancredo and every one of his immigration-hating dittoheads in Congress. The traditional American approach to immigration is the most successful in the world. Why anyone would want to dump it in favor of a policy of nativist exclusion is beyond me....

In the long run, reducing the tolerance for al-Qaeda and likeminded jihadist groups in the Middle East is the only way we'll ever permanently reduce the threat of Islamic terrorism. This — not military action — should be the single most important guiding principle of our foreign policy.
Stapling it to their heads wouldn't help; they still wouldn't get the message. It would sure be entertaining, though.

Friday, July 06, 2007

Immigration and Security

Victor Davis Hanson's latest, on immigration, is the usual mixture of dubious assumptions, half-truths, platitudes, misread polling data, and just plain craziness. You can skip all that. There's one line that encapsulates the nuttiness behind Hanson's (and the other wingnuts') nativist hysteria:

The public thinks anti-terrorism efforts are futile when hundreds of miles on our southern border are, for mysterious reasons, left wide open.
Yes, for reasons that are completely inexplicable, a 1,951-mile border between a wealthy country of 300 million people and a poorer country of 100 million has not been magically sealed so as to guarantee that nobody from the latter can ever enter the former illegally.

Go figure.

What Hanson never discusses is just what 'closing the border' would entail. A great big fence? As somebody or other said, if you build a 50-foot fence somebody else will build a 50-foot ladder. Massive troop deployment? I'm afraid our soldiers are otherwise occupied. Some kind of force field? Hasn't been invented yet.

The reality is that any solution that would be non-trivially effective would entail vast expenditures of money and personnel, neither of which would magically materialize; something else would have to be drastically shorted. In practice, 'closing the border' would make us less safe, not more, by diverting resources on a massive scale from more effective security measures (port safety, anyone?) to a hopeless and misdirected effort that even if it succeeded beyond the most improbable expectations would at best make us marginally less vulnerable in one particular aspect of the overal security situation.

In other words, 'closing the border' is exactly like 'victory in Iraq': an empty phrase that glosses over both the impossibility of the thing it describes and its irrelevance to the goals used to justify it.

Empty phrases, of course, are Hanson's shock troops in his own Global War on Liberal Ideas. For Hanson, for most of the wingnuts, there is no difference between an empty phrase and the thing it describes; to express the desire for 'victory in Iraq' is the same as achieving it. Practicalities aren't even an afterthought--they're not a thought at all, for Hanson. It doesn't matter that the war in Iraq has sown chaos across the Middle East, has weakened our military, has strengthened the very people who most want to attack us. What matters is that you use the right empty phrases to describe the thing.

What would really improve border security would be removing artificial barriers to legal entry. If the vast majority of people who want to come here to work could do so through official channels, the remainder would no longer pose the enforcement nightmare we have created for ourselves. The enormous resources we currently spend on catching people who have done nothing wrong beyond crossing an arbitrary and fictitious line in the sand could be redirected to real security measures. That's if, of course, we wanted to pursue a strategy based on practical effectiveness rather than conformity to the slogan du jour.

But then, if America wanted that, we wouldn't be in Iraq.

Friday, May 18, 2007

Immigration Derangement Syndrome

From what I've read so far, the immigration bill really kind of sucks. Sure, there's one positive aspect--a path to citizenship--but on the whole I think Nathan Newman's take is essentially correct:

I'm unimpressed by a deal that delays citizenship for up to 14 years for those being granted new "Z visas";
At the same time, the deal brings in 400,000 new guest workers each year with NO option for citizenship, the perfect second-tier workforce to undercut worker solidarity since they have no long-term future here;
And the abandonment of most family reuninfication in future legal immigration undercuts one of the most admirable real "pro-family" aspects of our immigration policy.
On the other hand, any bill that makes the wingnuts as angry as this (or this or this or this or this or this or this or this) has accomplished a worthwhile goal before it's even enacted.

I'm only partly joking there. If the 27 percenters are any indication, this will cause enormous damage to the Republican party. We're looking at a Tancredo surge--maybe into double digits--and a possible third-party candidate. We're looking at a lot of wingnuts staying home on election day. Yes, there's still the Vast Global Apocalyptic Struggle Against Islamofascist Terror to bring them in, but even that won't be enough for some. This is a direct affront to the xenophobia that is a core value of today's Republican party.

TIDOS Yankee signs off his post with this: "Goodbye, GOP." From his lips to the FSM's ears.

Update: Ezra Klein has more analysis of the bill. Atrios comments:
There's a lot of crazy in the current system, and amnesty-which-has-pointless-hurdles-so-we-don't-call-it-amnesty seems to add to the crazy. Border security is an expensive fantasy, and a guest worker program is just bad.
That sounds about right to me.

Tuesday, January 02, 2007

Vulnerable to Infiltration

Think Progress quotes nutcase Virgil Goode (emphasis mine):

Let us remember that we were not attacked by a nation on 9/11; we were attacked by extremists who acted in the name of the Islamic religion. I believe that if we do not stop illegal immigration totally, reduce legal immigration and end diversity visas, we are leaving ourselves vulnerable to infiltration by those who want to mold the United States into the image of their religion, rather than working within the Judeo-Christian principles that have made us a beacon for freedom-loving persons around the world.
Yes, we are.

Has anyone ever left themselves so open to so pithy a response? I think not.

Mr. Goode, we are indeed vulnerable to those who wish to change the United States by molding it into the image of their religion. You are one of those people.

(We must be ever vigilant against the dangers of cross-posts.)

[That's all, folks]

Wednesday, July 05, 2006

Bigots on Bikes Revisited, Yet Again

Frosty Wooldridge, the nativist demagogue who organized the 'Paul Revere Ride' against against illegal immigration, was kind enough to follow up his first comment with another:

In further reference to Hilton's 'silent-assertion' piece about the Paul Revere Riders, consider these realities caused by illegal aliens:

1. 16,000 cases of TB brought into the USA in five years in the bodies of unscreened illegal aliens. They are spreading it to our children and citizens.
2. MS-13 gangs now number 11,000 operating in 33 states according to Newsweek Magazine and distributing $128 billion in drugs annually to the US.
3. In Colorado, illegal aliens caused a 67% flunk out/drop out rate in Denver Public Schools last year and duplicated it again this year according to the Rocky Mountain News. I am a former tearcher in Colorado.
4. In Greeley, Colorado last year 270 hit and run accidents by illegals.
5. Three Coloradan killed by illegals in the last year by drunks and execution killings.
6. Colorado pays $40 million to house its illegal prisoners and nationally, the cost is $1.6 billion to house 600,000 illegals in federal and state prisons.
7. Illegals do not respect our laws or our language.
8. Illegals cheat by not paying income taxes and working off the books costs US citizens $310 billion in uncollected IRS income taxes annually according to the Bears-Stearns Report, 2005.
9. Illegals swamp and bankrupt our hospitals to the tune of 86 LA hospitals bankrupted in the last five years giving service to non paying illegals. CA is in debt to $38 billion and their schools are now in the bottom 5% of the nation.
10. The fact is, all illegals broke our federal laws and are federal criminals. We are either a lawful nation or a lawless nation.

Therefore, Mr. Hilton, when you talk about bigots, you need to turn your quill on yourself instead of others. I stand with integrity and you suffer something known as 'silent-assertion'.

Finally, as bright as you may be, write a piece and give one single advantage to adding 200 million people to the USA by mid century. I'm sure you'll come up with a brilliant idea on how to mitigate the horrific environmental consequences.

Frosty Wooldridge
www.frostywooldridge.com
www.21stcenturypaulrevereride.us
A few points in response:
  • The Bear Stearns study you cite is widely considered to be grossly exaggerated in its conclusions; in any case, you overstate the study's estimate of lost revenues by an order of magnitude. (Also, lost revenues are offset by Social Security paid in but never collected.)
  • You don't give a cite for the 200 million figure, but that's based on a Heritage Foundation study that is completely bogus. Think of it this way: how likely is it that the entire population of Mexico and Central America will wind up in the U.S.?
  • People who commit a misdemeanor are not generally considered 'criminals', and wishful thinking (your desire to raise the offense of being 'illegal' to a felony) doesn't make them so.
  • Whatever ill effects there may be from immigration, making it illegal exacerbates them. Make them legal and a lot of those problems (lost revenues, e.g) suddenly go away.
  • As for the bigotry thing, I think the contempt with which you speak of foreigners who happen to be slightly darker than yourself is evidence enough for the charge; but I'll add to that the fact that you link to, and allow your writing to be posted at, a hate site like Vdare.
  • I don't think any assertion I made was particularly silent, so I'm not sure what you mean by that. Your use of Clemens (who in his own day abhorred your kind of prejudice) as if today he would endorse your position is a grotesque travesty.
[That's all, folks]

Sunday, June 25, 2006

Bigots on Bikes Revisited

A couple of weeks ago I wrote about a nativist demagogue named Frosty Wooldridge. Mr. Wooldridge was kind enough to leave a comment to that post, which I post in its entirety below, followed by my response:

Tom Hilton needs to get a life and an understanding before he writes about what he does not know. I write about this invasion much like Thomas Paine and Mark Twain wrote: Facts and realities we face. I have never written about legal immigration. This is about breaking our laws; this is about breaking over our borders; this is about lawlessness of ILLEGAL immigration. Hilton is one who supports anarchy by supporting lawlessness to the tune of 20 million. Get a grip young man. We're being invaded and you're making apologizes! Being a coward does not become you as an American. I am against illegal immigration, period.

Mark Twain said that the shabbiest of all lies is 'silent-assertion' which is when the media, leaders and others ignore or suppress a social wrong. In his time, it was slavery. Today, it's illegal immigration and the nightmare of multiculturalism which has been shown to be a miserable failure and dangerous to the host country which I noted in Paris, France as I was there last summer along with Holland where I interviewed dozens. They said they will have a civil war within a few years: "The Dutch against our immigrants." Therefore, We're in trouble and I will not allow my country to continue into this laweless slide into a nightmare for all citizens. We're either a lawful nation or we are a lawless nation. Additionally, name one advantage of adding 2,000,000 million people by 2050. Not even a fool can name one advantage with our current environmental nightmares and lack of water, especially in the West. Again, sir, do your homework before you expose your lack of understanding. www.frostywooldridge.com
I encourage people to visit Mr. Woodridge's website and judge for yourselves whether my assessment is accurate. I'll add a couple of comments (below the fold):
  • Your comments on 'multiculturalism' (here and in your other writings) conflict with the claim that you oppose only illegal immigration. If the presence of non-Anglo cultures in America is a 'nightmare', then it is a 'nightmare' regardless of the legal status of the immigrants.

  • The realities of immigration policy do not support your conclusions. Nations that offer immigrants a clear path to citizenship (like the U.S.) have, on the whole, less of a problem with immigration than nations that don't (like France).

  • The 'lawlessness' argument ("this is about lawlessness of ILLEGAL immigration") is essentially circular: they are breaking the law because they are defined as 'illegal'; cease to define them as 'illegal' and they become law-abiding immigrants.

  • I'm not sure where the 'coward' thing comes from, as I'm not the one who lives in terror of people who are different from me.

  • On the other hand, I've not been called 'young' for many a year. Thank you.
[That's all, folks]

Tuesday, June 20, 2006

Lies, Damned Lies, and the Immigration Debate

Carolyn Lochhead (whom I have criticized fairly harshly in the past) has a must-read article about a bogus alarmist study on immigration from the Heritage Foundation that, implausible as it was, wound up framing the immigration debate in the Senate. The article speaks for itself, so I'll just add a couple of thoughts:

  • Study from the Heritage Foundation turns out to be completely off the mark? Well, duh.
  • And yet, people bought it...illustrating the fundamental calculation of the right: no matter how factually wrong or flatly unbelievable a 'fact' is, it will still provide cover for people who otherwise have nothing to support their position.
  • Dianne Feinstein cited the Heritage study on the floor of the Senate, and changed her position on the basis of it. Jesusfuckingchrist Dianne, whatthefuckwereyouthinking?
[That's all, folks]

Thursday, June 15, 2006

Bigots on Bikes Get a Pass from the Chron

Yesterday's Chronicle ran a story on an unique immigration protest: five motorcyclists who call themselves the Paul Revere Riders, crossing the country to sound the alarm about illegal immigrants. Here's a representative sample:

"One if by land, two if by sea, three if from Mexico," declares their Web site -- comparing illegal migrants from Mexico to British redcoats of two centuries ago.

"The idea is to get enough people enough excited about their country to take action," said leader Frosty Wooldridge when the group arrived in Los Gatos Tuesday evening. "Paul Revere in April of 1775 was the great communicator. He rode and spread the word and actually beat the British. We're trying to spread the word through our neighbors and through the Internet.

"We've seen people march for anarchy, march for Mexico, march for illegality," said Wooldridge, who hopes legal immigration will be reduced dramatically and illegal entries stopped altogether. "It's time we as Americans stand up."
The story quotes exactly five people: the leader, and four of the anti-immigration protestors. All had positive things to say about the ride, and about the anti-immigration cause. Nobody was quoted with anything critical to say. A story on a politically charged protest ends up coming off as a human interest story.

Just to be clear, I don't think the reporter, Tyche Hendricks, has an agenda here. Hendricks has written similarly uncritical reports on pro-immigration rallies, and has occasionally done excellent reporting on the issue (including a piece about the historical elephant in the room: the Bracero program of the '40s and '50s, which amounted to the legalized and systematized exploitation of Mexican 'guest' workers for the benefit of agribusiness). Still, to report on such an inflammatory protest without any negative comment is just...odd. Besides, of course, being sloppy reporting.

But it isn't the sloppiest thing about this story. The human in this human interest story, Frosty Wooldridge, happens to be a fairly prolific writer; there is much more to judge him on than just a softball piece in the Chron.

Like this:
Multi-culturalism scorched the streets of Paris! Multi-culturalism burns and kills in France, Holland, Belgium, Germany and Britain. Recent violence corroborates that disparate cultures cannot exist together....Americans roll over and sleep as the Muslim and Mexican invasion accelerates in the United States.
Or this:
Jay Leno is one of the few left in LA who speaks English. High school race riots in LA are common. Blacks and Mexicans coexist with razor sharp tension. Educational standards degrade into meaninglessness in California schools faster than you can flip a burger. Crime grows by the day as Mexicans imbed further into the systems faster than laws can imprison them.
Or this:
Southern France is now known as Northern Nigeria. Over five million Muslims own Southern France. They are not French, don’t speak French, and don’t respect France as French....[The French] will either lose their country and language, or wall off southern France to the immigrants to save themselves.
Or this:
Have you noticed dozens of languages being spoken by citizens and illegal aliens in America? Do you feel the disrespect and the separation? Do you feel violated? ...Do you feel like your country is being stolen from you along with your language?
Or this:
Political correctness is killing America. Our leaders wielding the mighty ax of political correctness will be shown in the history books to have murdered the United States of America. Its blood will drain out of its citizens as an advancing horde of illegal alien migrants kills America’s ability to function....Bob from New Jersey said, “What did generations of my family fight and die for in wars? Get the illegals out, close the borders and move them into internment camps until we get things sorted."
Wooldridge's writings are filled with this sort of xenophobic racism. Like the Minutemen, Wooldridge is in the business of mainstreaming hate.

The Chronicle has a history of failing to report on the background or associations of right-wing activists. (Maybe they're no worse than most papers, and I just notice it because I read the Chronicle more often; I don't know.) This one is particularly dangerous, though. Just as Wooldridge is mainstreaming hate, the Chronicle, by failing to highlight his ugly side, is helping to mainstream Wooldridge.

[Cross-posted at Property of a Lady]

[That's all, folks]

Friday, May 12, 2006

Immigration and Illegality


Last week I said I thought that what drags down wages in illegal immigration isn't the immigration but the illegality. Here's a story that would appear to support that:

Sonia Cano was happy to win thousands of dollars from the San Francisco taqueria that for two years had paid her less than the city minimum wage. But she may have lost far more when someone anonymously reported her and her husband to immigration authorities.

Cano and her husband, Carlos Barrancos, illegal immigrants from Mexico, were reported to federal authorities in November. Cano was eight months pregnant at the time and gave birth to their baby in San Francisco alone -- while Barrancos was in an Arizona immigration jail....

Cradling her 4-month-old son on Wednesday, Cano said she filed a complaint with the city's Office of Labor Standards Enforcement in June after she learned that her employer, Si Señor Taqueria, wasn't paying the city's minimum wage. Days later, the Financial District restaurant fired her, she said.

The city investigated her claim and concluded that Si Señor owed Cano and 13 other employees more than $22,000 in back wages, said Donna Levitt, who heads the labor enforcement office. She said Si Señor has paid the workers what they were owed.

Seville and Young Workers United, a nonprofit organization that organizes restaurant workers, helped Cano file complaints with the city and state over her firing and began negotiating with the restaurant.

Then, early one morning in December, immigration agents knocked on the couple's apartment door and arrested Barrancos.
First: 'anonymous' my ass. I think we all know who phoned in the tip.

Second: this illustrates vividly how 'illegal' workers have no bargaining power at all. Yes, the law said she was entitled to be paid minimum wage (in the first place), and to back wages (when that didn't happen); and yes, it actually worked out that way in this case. In the end, her employer was still able to screw her because she was arbitrarily defined as 'illegal'.

Nor is that unusual:
Many employers do use the threat of deportation against illegal immigrants who try to assert their rights in the workplace, said Katie Quan, chair of the UC Berkeley Labor Center. That led the AFL-CIO to change its policy on immigration in 2000 and support legalization for undocumented workers who are already in the United States, she added.
This is heartening news to those of us who remember the wrongheaded policies labor had on immigration back in the '80s. Because Quan is exactly right:
"If we allow a situation where certain workers are not entitled to the same rights as other workers, then we're essentially creating an underclass, a substandard tier of workers," Quan said. "This will only encourage employers to employ more workers who are undocumented ... . The standards and rights of everyone are eroded when there's an underclass created."
[That's all, folks]

Thursday, May 04, 2006

Immigration Question

So there's this study everyone is talking about that purports to show that illegal immigration from 1980 to 2000 reduced wages at the low end by a net 3.6%. Fine, as far as it goes.

What I want to know is: how much of the effect is due to the immigration, and how much is due to the illegality?

The reason illegal immigrants work for low wages is that they have zero bargaining power because they're 'illegal'. 'Legal' workers can complain to the state if they're getting paid less than minimum wage; 'illegal' workers, obviously, can't. It seems to me the problem is that defining certain people as 'illegal' is what depresses wages.

But I'm not an economist, so I could be completely full of shit on this. Does anyone have enough expertise, or know anyone with enough expertise, to tell me if I'm missing something?

[That's all, folks]

Saturday, April 15, 2006

Something There Is That Does Not Love a Wall

Rick Oltman, a spokesman for the Federation for American Immigration Reform, which favors stricter limits on immigration, said a fence would do more to cut the death toll than establishing a guest-worker program would.

"The answer is deterrence," he said. "The most humane thing to do is to let people know they're not going to make it so they don't risk their lives."
--San Francisco Chronicle, April 14, 2006

In the 28 years of its existence, the wall claimed at least 86 victims. In reality the death toll was higher, much higher probably. However, this is hard to tell, even now, as such deaths were not recorded properly by the authorities of the Democratic Republic of Germany (Deutsche Demokratische Republik, DDR)....The first victim of the wall was Günter Litfin. He was 24 years old. He was shot by transportation police, near the station of Berlin Friedrichstrasse. They tried to stop his attempt to get away. This was on 24th August, 1961, only 11 days after the inner-german border had been closed.

Peter Fechter bled to death in the death strip, on 17th August, 1962. This lead to a public outcry. American troops were watching him bleed, but could not do anything. East-German border police (who had wounded him), did not act....

In 1966, two children, aged 10 and 13 years, were killed by at least 40 gunshots in the border strip. This is unusual because the German border police had explicit orders not to shoot on pregnant women, children or mentally ill people.

The last deadly case took place on 6th February,1989. In the incident,Chris Gueffroy bled to death.
--Wikipedia entry, "Berlin Wall"


[That's all, folks]

Friday, April 14, 2006

A Case for Immigration Reform

Realistically, the status quo is probably better than any immigration bill that this Congress could conceivably pass.

Better...but still not good:

The number of Mexican migrants who died attempting to come work in the United States climbed to a record high of 516 last year, almost 40 percent more than in 2004, according to figures compiled by the Mexican government.

Record heat last summer and an American border control strategy that induced people to trek across more remote areas were largely to blame, Border Patrol officials and immigration analysts have said.
Reducing demand through employer-side enforcement might help. Increasing the (ridiculously low) immigration quotas would certainly help. Even a guest worker program, as odious as it is in other ways, would probably reduce deaths among would-be immigrants.

The one thing that will absolutely not work is a great big fence. If anything, it would exacerbate the problem by making would-be immigrants more dependant than ever on coyotes to get them across. In other words, it would take the most vulnerable and make them still more vulnerable to the least scrupulous people around. That must be why it's so appealing to so many Republicans.

In any case, this is a reminder of why, sooner or later--probably not this year, maybe not for another few years, but eventually--we need to come up with a more humane way to do this.

[That's all, folks]